The research
Training guides
I compared.
The published training plans I checked my Cowtown plan against, what each one does, and where mine is the same or different. Each guide links to the official plan, so you can check my reading. For what I actually changed, see how my plan was built.
Bottom line
What the comparison found
I first ran this comparison on Nov 7, 2026 and added runDisney on Nov 12. Where my plan has changed since, it says so.
- Mostly aligned. Five mostly short run days, cutback weeks, lifting on other days, easy runs by effort, and a 2:1 run/walk all match what the guides do.
- Biggest gap: my marathon peak and taper came early and dropped steeply. My 20-miler was 6 weeks before Cowtown, with long runs then falling 14, 12, 10, 6, 0. All four B.A.A. levels (even novice) put the biggest long run 3 weeks out, Nike puts it 4 weeks out, and every plan keeps long runs at 10 miles or more until the last week. Fixed Nov 7: the peak moved to Jan 30, 4 weeks out.
- Second gap: a 10-mile long run one week before the Dec 12 half. Nike’s half plan goes no longer than 7 miles in the last two weeks. Fixed Nov 7: Dec 5 is now 7 miles.
- Smaller gap: very little faster running. Every guide has at least one quality session a week, even for beginners. Partly closed Nov 7 with two fartleks. I’m keeping speed work light on purpose because of my knee.
The guides
What I read
| Guide | Length | Run days | Peak week | Longest run |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B.A.A. Boston Marathon, Level 1 (novice) | 20 weeks | about 4 | 40 mi (starts at 25) | 16 to 18 mi |
| B.A.A. Level 2 | 20 weeks | about 5 | 45 mi (starts at 30) | 18 to 20 mi |
| B.A.A. Levels 3 and 4 | 20 weeks | 6 to 7 | 55 to 60 mi | 20 to 22 mi |
| Nike Run Club Marathon | 18 weeks | 3, 4 or 5 | not given | 18 to 22 mi |
| Nike Run Club Half Marathon | 14 weeks | 3, 4 or 5 | not given | 12.5 mi |
| Nike Run Club 10K | 8 weeks | 5 | not given | 6.2 mi (app version) |
| Nike Run Club 5K | 8 weeks | 5 | not given | 4 mi |
| runDisney plans by Jeff Galloway (four plans) | 11 weeks and up | 3 | not given | 26 to 27 mi (marathon plans) |
| Galloway run-walk-run | A method, not a plan: run/walk ratios by pace and how to progress them | |||
B.A.A. Levels 3 and 4 are far beyond me, but they’re useful for seeing when experienced plans put the peak.
Marathon
Peak and taper
Long run by weeks before race day. Cowtown is Sunday Feb 28, so a Saturday Jan 16 run is 6 weeks out. The last column is my plan as it stood on Nov 7, before I changed it.
| Weeks out | Nike Marathon | B.A.A. Level 1 | B.A.A. Level 2 | B.A.A. Level 3 | My plan, Nov 7 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6 | 16 to 18 mi | 14 to 17 (race-pace simulation) | 16 to 19 (simulation) | 16 to 19 (simulation) | 20 mi (peak) |
| 5 | 90 min | 14 (10 at race pace) | 14 | 14 | 14 mi |
| 4 | 18 to 22 mi (peak) | 12 to 14 easy | 11 to 13 easy | 17 to 20 | 12 mi |
| 3 | 15 to 16 mi | 15 to 18 (peak simulation) | 18 to 20 (peak simulation) | 18 to 20 (peak simulation) | 10 mi |
| 2 | 12 to 14 mi | 13 to 14 (6 to 8 at race pace) | 14 to 15 | 13 to 14 | 6 mi |
| 1 | 10 mi | 5 to 7 (plus an 8 mi workout) | 7 to 8 | 8 to 10 | none |
| Race week | race | 2 to 3 mi | 2 to 3 mi | 2 to 3 mi | 5K Sat, marathon Sun |
What it meant: every B.A.A. level, including the novice plan, puts the biggest long run 3 weeks out, and Nike puts it 4 weeks out. Every plan still has a 12 to 15 mile run 2 weeks out, then a short taper. My long runs were falling for 5 straight weeks after the peak, so I’d have gone into Cowtown with my longest run far behind me.
What I changed on Nov 7:
| Week | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Jan 9 | 18 | 16 |
| Jan 16 | 20 | 18 |
| Jan 23 | 14 | 12 (cutback) |
| Jan 30 | 12 | 20 (peak, 4 weeks out) |
| Feb 6 | 10 | 14 |
| Feb 13 | 6 | 10 |
| Feb 20 | none | 6 |
That keeps one 20-miler and the same cutback rhythm, with the peak in Nike’s spot. The B.A.A. would go one week later still. Four weeks leaves more room to recover, which suits a run of over four hours. Since Nov 12, the 20 has to be earned on Jan 16 and ends at 4:00 elapsed. If my knee or recovery complains, capping the peak at 18 is what the B.A.A. novice plan does anyway.
Marathon
Weekly load
| B.A.A. Level 1 | B.A.A. Level 2 | My plan now | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Run days | about 4 | about 5 | 5 (most of them 3 miles), plus easy walks |
| Peak week | 40 mi | 45 mi | 36 mi |
| Longest run | 16 to 18 mi | 18 to 20 mi | up to 20 mi |
| Longest run vs. peak week | about 45% | about 44% | about 56% (20 of 36) |
| Non-run days | cross-training or strength | same | lifting 5 days, Sunday rest |
My weekly miles are in line with a novice plan for a finish goal. The long run is a bigger slice of my week than in either B.A.A. level. The B.A.A. percentages are rough: they compare each plan’s longest run with its biggest week, which may not be the same week. There’s no proven injury line at any percentage, and adding weekday miles just to shrink the share would add work, so if the long run feels like too much, I shorten it and let the week’s total drop.
How B.A.A. Level 1 lays out a week: Monday off, runs Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday and Sunday, and strength or cross-training Wednesday and Friday. It often runs Saturday and Sunday back to back (easy, then long).
Speed
Faster running
- Nike has speed runs from week 1 in every plan, even the 5K (8 × 1:00 at 5K pace with 1:00 easy). The half plan has two a week (intervals, fartlek, tempo or hills). The marathon plan has about one a week.
- Nike’s “One Hard Two Easy” fartlek (1:00 hard, 2:00 easy, for 21 minutes) is a natural first speed session for me. Both parts are running. (I first wrote that it has the same shape as my 2:1 run/walk. It doesn’t: the fartlek is 1 part hard to 2 parts easy running, and my run/walk is 2 parts running to 1 part walking.)
- The B.A.A. uses hill repeats (200 to 400 m uphill at 10K pace), 1K repeats, half-marathon-pace miles and race-pace blocks inside long runs. Even the novice plan has 2 or 3 quality sessions most weeks.
What I took from it: going from almost no faster running to 3 sessions a week would be too big a jump for my knee, so I added one kind at a time. My plan now has short hills every two to three weeks, fartleks on Dec 30 and Jan 27, and race rehearsals at the end of the Jan 9 and Jan 16 long runs.
Dec 12 half
The last weeks before a half
| Weeks out | Nike Half | My plan, Nov 7 |
|---|---|---|
| 4 | 12.5 mi | 8 mi (Nov 14) |
| 3 | 60 min run | 10 mi (Nov 21) |
| 2 | 7 mi | 11 mi (Fri Nov 27) |
| 1 | race week: 25 min, 2 mi and short intervals | 10 mi (Dec 5) |
Nike’s long-run peak is 4 weeks out. Mine built right up to the week before the race. I’ve already run 13.1, so volume isn’t the question. Freshness for a PR attempt is. Changed Nov 7: Dec 5 is now a 7-mile race-morning rehearsal.
Nike 10K
The app version
The 10K plan as the Nike Run Club app laid it out for me. Every week has 5 runs and 2 rest days. It’s gentler than the sample weeks on Nike’s website, which fits Nike saying the app adapts the plan to your level.
| Weeks out | Speed run | Long run |
|---|---|---|
| 8 | 27 min intervals | 2.5 mi |
| 7 | 25 min intervals | 3.1 mi |
| 6 | 20 min fartlek | 3.7 mi |
| 5 | 26 min speed run | 4.9 mi |
| 4 | 5K tempo run | 5.6 mi |
| 3 | 27 min hill workout | 6.2 mi (peak) |
| 2 | 27 min fartlek | 4.9 mi |
| 1 | 3.7 mi, moved early in the week | 6.2 mi = race day |
- Same peak timing as the B.A.A. The biggest long run comes 3 weeks out, it steps down 2 weeks out, and race week is short and easy.
- Long runs grow by 0.5 to 1.2 miles a week. That’s gentle, like my Base phase.
- A speed run every week, and the type rotates. Even in race week the hard run doesn’t disappear. It moves early in the week and gets shorter.
runDisney
Jeff Galloway’s runDisney plans
Added Nov 12: four public runDisney plans, all written by Jeff Galloway, runDisney’s official training consultant. They’re the Experienced Marathon plan (11 weeks), the Beginner Half plan (18 weeks), the Goofy Challenge plan (a half Saturday, then a full Sunday) and the Dopey Challenge plan (5K and 10K, then a half, then a full). The Goofy and Dopey PDFs came through with garbled layouts, so their week-by-week numbers here are approximate.
| runDisney (Galloway) | My plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Run days | 3: 30 to 45 min on Tue and Thu, plus the weekend long run | 5, most of them 3 miles. Kept on purpose |
| Other days | Optional cross-training. Goofy says to avoid stair machines and leg weights | Lifting 5 days, with leg day kept away from long runs |
| Long runs | Every other week in the late build, with a short 3 to 5 miles in between | Every week, with cutbacks every few weeks |
| Longest run | 26 to 27 mi, about 3 weeks out, very slow with lots of walking | Up to 20 mi, 4 weeks out |
| Run/walk at 10:45 to 12:15 a mile | 1:00 run, 0:30 walk | 2:00 / 1:00 (tried 1:00 / 0:30 on Nov 21 and it felt harder) |
| Long-run pace | At least 2 min a mile slower than predicted marathon pace | About 11:00 a mile lately, quicker than that |
| Heat | About 1 min a mile slower at 70°F, another minute at 80°F | Adopted Nov 12 |
| Magic Mile | About every 2 weeks, 3 to 4 times. First one not all-out | 3 (November, January, February) |
| Magic Mile math | Half pace = mile time × 1.3. All-out marathon pace = mile time × 1.4 | Adopted Nov 12 (the site used × 1.2 and × 1.3 before) |
| Back-to-back races | Mostly walk the first race to save energy for the second | Adopted Nov 12 for the Cowtown 5K |
- The same 2:1 ratio, in shorter pieces. Galloway’s 1:00 run / 0:30 walk is the same split as my 2:00 / 1:00, with shorter segments, which he says lowers fatigue.
- A bigger heat adjustment than the one I’d been using (about 30 seconds a mile per 5 degrees).
- The 26 to 27 mile training runs are the big difference. They’re Galloway’s signature, run very slowly with lots of walking. Every other guide tops out at 20 to 22 miles, and I stayed with them.
Run/walk
Galloway’s ratios
| Pace per mile | Starting ratio |
|---|---|
| Slower than 12:00 | 15 to 30 s run / 30 to 60 s walk |
| 10:00 to 12:00 | 2:00 run / 1:00 walk |
| 9:00 to 10:00 | 4:00 run / 1:00 walk |
| 8:00 to 9:00 | 6:00 to 8:00 run / 0:30 to 1:00 walk |
- My long runs are around 11:00 a mile and I race at 2:1, so I’m right on Galloway’s setting for that pace.
- He says to change the ratio only in blocks of 2 to 3 weeks, only once long runs feel strong, and to test the race ratio on 2 or 3 long runs before race day.
- My Cowtown plan of 13:30 to 13:45 a mile is an overall pace, walks included. At 2:00 / 1:00 that means running segments of about 11:45 to 12:00 a mile, right at the edge of Galloway’s 2:00 / 1:00 band. If my running segments slow past 12:00 late in the race, in heat or on hills, his table says walk more, so 1:00 / 0:30 or 1:00 / 1:00 is the fallback.
Paces
The B.A.A. pace chart
The B.A.A. chart gives paces per mile for each goal time. These are the three slowest goals it lists:
| Goal time | Marathon pace | Half pace | Easy runs | Aerobic runs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4:30 | 10:20 | 9:50 | 11:40 | 11:08 |
| 4:45 | 10:55 | 10:25 | 12:25 | 11:45 |
| 5:00 | 11:30 | 10:55 | 13:10 | 12:25 |
- The chart stops at a 5:00 marathon. My goals (finish first, aiming for under 6:00, about 5:00 as a reach) is at or past its slowest column, so these are a ceiling for me, not targets.
- Something to watch: my Nov 7 long run was 11:06 a mile on Strava. By this chart that’s 5:00 marathon pace, and faster than its easy pace for a 5:00 runner. My easy runs run a little hot, so effort and heart rate, not pace, are the guide.
Already there
Already in line with the guides
- 5 run days most weeks, between B.A.A. Level 1 and Level 2, and the same as Nike’s 5-day option.
- Cutback weeks every 3 to 4 weeks.
- Strength on other days (the B.A.A. lists strength or cross-training on non-run days).
- Easy runs by effort, not pace. The B.A.A. calls easy “conversational,” and Nike rates effort out of 10.
- Nike’s plans say to treat the plan as written in pencil and to space hard days apart. That’s how my schedule already works around group runs and lifting.
Receipts
Sources
- B.A.A. Boston Marathon training plans (read Nov 7)
- Nike marathon plan, half marathon plan, 10K plan and 5K plan, plus the Nike Run Club app version of the 10K (read Nov 7)
- Galloway run-walk-run ratios, RunnersConnect (read Nov 7)
- runDisney plans by Jeff Galloway: Experienced Marathon, Beginner Half, Goofy Challenge and Dopey Challenge (read Nov 12)
- My own plan table and how my plan was built